Podcast: Download

SSA059: In a lavender field in Sichuan province stands something shaped exactly like a country church — steeple, roofline, a cross — assembled from hundreds of slender white aluminum tubes and nothing else. No walls. No roof. No altar. Architecture magazines call it the Shadowless Church and praise it for the way light and air pass straight through, for the way it barely seems to be there at all. That last quality is the point. It is also the problem.

Kathryn Laffrey brings it to Alix Murray as the latest rabbit hole, and it turns into one of the sharper questions this show asks: what is a church, once you subtract everything a church is for?

It sits in the Sino-French Agricultural Science and Technology Park, a joint venture whose whole aesthetic argument is southern France — Provence, lavender rows, the light of Impressionism. Read that way, it is a painting rendered in metal. Read another way, Alix says, it ticks every box of a materialist worldview and not one transcendental box. The architecture press discusses ingenuity, reflectivity, and the fact that aluminum will not rot. Nobody discusses meaning.

Kathryn’s objection arrives from the opposite direction. Yes, it has the silhouette. But a church is more than its shape.She works in liturgical embroidery, so her mind goes to what an open sky means: you would certainly need a pall, because anything at all could fall into the precious species. Nothing here suggests permanence, as Alix puts it — and she suspects that is deliberate.

Then the comparison that gives the episode its weight. Hiking in the Scottish hills, Alix says, you sometimes come across the bones of an animal, bleached white. That is what this is: a carcass in a lavender field, the remains of something that is not there anymore. On a foggy day the photographs turn ghostly.

Which raises the question neither host will settle. This is China, where Christians have faced severe persecution and an underground Catholic Church exists alongside a state-sanctioned one that claims the authority to appoint its own bishops. Is a church built to disappear a protest? A gesture toward believers who worship out of sight? Or a beautiful object with no argument in it at all?

It is not only a Chinese phenomenon — Kathryn points to the glass chapels of the Arkansas Ozarks, built on the reasoning that walls only obstruct the view.

The two land in the same place. Good architecture and the natural world should enhance one another; a stone cottage in a lavender field is lovely, while this is harsh against everything around it. Beauty matters, and human beings carry a responsibility to shape the material world in a dignified way that gives glory to God. Kathryn’s prescription is blunt: put walls on it. Put a roof on it. Put in an altar and a crucifix. Claim Christ.

Get all new episodes automatically and for free:

Follow by Email | Watch this episode and subscribe on YouTube.

Help us continue to offer The Secrets of Sacred Art. Won’t you make a pledge at SQPN.com/give today?

Links for this episode:

• Leave us a review on Apple Podcasts!
• Email us feedback or comments to [email protected]

Want to Sponsor A Show?
Support StarQuest’s mission to explore the intersection of faith and pop culture by becoming a named sponsor of the show of your choice on the StarQuest network. Click to get started or find out more.