The Ninth Jedi, Episode 8: The Ninth Jedi

SSW273: The Ninth Jedi is over, at least for now, and the villain is still breathing.

Episode 8, “The Ninth Jedi,” closes out Star Wars: Visions Presents – The Ninth Jedi, and Thomas Salerno and Jeff Haecker call it a solid finale: familiar Star Wars storytelling in an anime coat, and to Thomas it feels like comfort food.

The finale turns on one fight. Lah Zhima confronts his former student first, off screen. Then Lah Kara faces Nawaam on the hull of his crashed fortress while the other Jedi try to break the giant kyber crystal in his cannon. Thomas says every great lightsaber duel is a test of wills as much as a physical fight, and this one proves it. Kara tells Nawaam she can still see the little boy who watched a killing he should never have seen. His philosophy of nothingness turns out to be the oldest Sith idea there is: strength decides what is good. Evil, Thomas says, never has a new idea.

Then the colors change. Kara’s silver blade turns green, like Juro’s. Nawaam’s turns red, and Thomas feels vindicated: if it walks like a Sith and quacks like a Sith, it is a Sith.

Nawaam also claims that empathy makes the Jedi weak. Thomas pushes back hard. Compassion is what makes Kara strong, and the Jedi exist to defend the defenseless, which is the calling her father lost sight of while hunting the Sith one by one. Jeff brings in the prequel Jedi, so caught up in politics that ordinary people never met one, and the High Republic’s Wayseekers and small outpost temples. Thomas compares those temples to Franciscan and Dominican priories, and the late Republic Jedi to the Knights Templar.

The ending turns on mercy. Kara’s strike never cuts. She shut her blade off at the last instant without knowing it, and Nawaam lives to sit in a cell. Zhima brings him a new lightsaber, and the screen goes black before we see its color. Is it a test? The hosts weigh redemption against justice, and Thomas recalls a 1990s Legends trilogy whose villain repents but pays almost nothing for his crimes.

So who is the ninth Jedi? Juro, the order’s founder? Bee-Toh, the last to take up a lightsaber? Nawaam, if he turns? They also look at the new Jedi Order, in white robes at a literal round table, which fits the Arthurian thread Thomas saw back in the first short. They ask why the Jedi didn’t simply lift the crystal out with the Force, whether kyber crystals are alive, and how the whole series held together, from the 2021 short through “Child of Hope.” Finally, what they’d like to see if Lucasfilm makes more: Homen’s story, the wider galaxy, maybe a lost Sith order, and more of the Visions shorts given room to grow.

Get all new episodes automatically and for free:


Follow by Email | Listen to this episode and subscribe on YouTube.

Help us continue to offer the Secrets of Star Wars. Won’t you make a pledge at SQPN.com/give today?

Links for this episode:

Want to Sponsor A Show?
Support StarQuest’s mission to explore the intersection of faith and pop culture by becoming a named sponsor of the show of your choice on the StarQuest network. Click to get started or find out more.