Podcast: Download

MYS443: In 2014, a year after he resigned the papacy, Pope Benedict XVI sat down to answer a letter from Italian philosopher of science Paolo Musso. Musso had four questions: did humanity descend from one couple, how should we understand original sin, could intelligent alien life exist, and what would that mean for Christ? Benedict’s private reply stayed out of public view until Musso printed it in his 2021 textbook La vita extraterrestre. Is the letter genuine, and what did the former pope say about aliens?

Jimmy Akin and Dom Bettinelli bring Jimmy’s full episode on the letter over from The Jimmy Akin Podcast. Jimmy checks the letterhead, the signature and the German traces in Benedict’s Italian, looks at who Musso is and how the letter reached him by Vatican diplomatic courier, and asks what weight a retired pope’s private opinion should carry.

Then the letter itself. On polygenism, Jimmy reads Pius XII’s Humani Generis closely, follows the debate that came after it, and shows how the International Theological Commission’s Communion and Stewardship left room for both one first couple and a first population. On original sin, Benedict points to Archbishop André-Joseph Léonard, whose proposal Jimmy sets beside ideas from Hans Urs von Balthasar and St. Gregory of Nyssa. On aliens, Benedict mentions C. S. Lewis’s Space Trilogy and gives his own view, and he closes with the cosmic reach of Christ’s victory.

After that comes a new segment made just for Mysterious World, starting at 1:05:05. For years, writers in the field of exopolitics have said the Vatican has proof of aliens and is preparing the world for disclosure. Jimmy walks through Michael Salla‘s predictions about Pope Francis and Pope Leo XIV, the 1933 Magenta UFO crash story, David Grusch‘s claim that the pope tipped off the Americans, and the controlled-disclosure thesis of Exo-Vaticana. Then he asks the obvious question: Joseph Ratzinger spent more than 23 years at the head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which kept the Third Secret of Fatima in its archives, before becoming pope. Was he in a position to know, and does his letter fit a Vatican hiding aliens?

The episode closes with your feedback on episode 432, the Shepherd of Hermas.

Get all new episodes automatically and for free:

Follow by Email | Watch this episode and subscribe on YouTube

Help us continue to offer Jimmy Akin’s Mysterious World. Won’t you make a pledge at SQPN.com/give today?

Links for this episode:

• Paolo Musso, La vita extraterrestre (Edizioni Studium, 2021)
• Cris Putnam and Thomas Horn, Exo-Vaticana (Defender, 2013)
• Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, The Message of Fatima (2000)
• Holy See Press Office, biographical notes on Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger
• Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, historical profile
• Michael Salla, “Pope Leo XIV & Vatican will lead official Extraterrestrial Disclosure,” Exopolitics (2025)
• Michael Salla, “Vatican preparing statement on extraterrestrial life,” Exopolitics (2014)
• Ashley Turner, “Vatican Helped Recover Alien UFO, Whistleblower David Grusch Claims,” PopCulture.com (2023)
• Susie Pinto, “No UFO records in Vatican archives despite whistleblower claim: Source,” NewsNation (2026)
• Roberto Pinotti, “The UFO Files of Mussolini,” The Black Vault

• Please spread the word about the podcast. Leave us a review on Apple Podcasts!
• Purchase the books and other material from this and other episodes at the Mysterious World Bookstore.
• Join the conversation at the Starquest Facebook page and the Jimmy Akin’s Mysterious World Facebook page.
• Be part of the StarQuest Discord community at SQPN.com/discord
• Send your feedback or comments to [email protected] or send a tweet to @mys_world
• You can also leave a voice message on the Mysterious Feedback Line at (619) 738-4515

Chapters:

• 0:00:00 – Intro
• 0:01:41 – A Crossover Episode
• 0:03:50 – The Jimmy Akin Podcast: Benedict XVI on Adam and Aliens
• 0:04:51 – Is the Letter Authentic?
• 0:09:14 – Who Is Paolo Musso?
• 0:15:07 – What Authority Does the Letter Have?
• 0:19:42 – How Musso Received the Letter
• 0:22:22 – Musso’s Four Questions
• 0:25:20 – Benedict’s Introduction and the Problem of Geocentrism
• 0:29:58 – What Is Polygenism?
• 0:31:07 – Pius XII and Humani Generis
• 0:37:08 – Communion and Stewardship
• 0:41:53 – Benedict on Polygenism
• 0:45:16 – Benedict on Original Sin
• 0:46:20 – Archbishop Léonard’s Proposal
• 0:49:47 – Von Balthasar and Gregory of Nyssa
• 0:52:54 – Benedict on Intelligent Aliens
• 0:57:36 – Christ’s Cosmic Triumph
• 1:01:19 – Benedict’s Position of Openness
• 1:03:04 – Thank you to Patrons
• 1:03:34 – Sponsor: Fr. Dwight Longenecker
• 1:04:24 – Sponsor: Gravetending Solutions
• 1:05:05 – New Segment: Benedict’s Letter and the Vatican UFO Claims
• 1:06:10 – What Is Exopolitics?
• 1:06:53 – Michael Salla and Pope Leo XIV
• 1:09:24 – The Magenta UFO Crash
• 1:10:10 – David Grusch and the Vatican
• 1:12:35 – Controlled Disclosure and Exo-Vaticana
• 1:14:14 – Salla’s 2014 Prediction
• 1:16:24 – Was Benedict in a Position to Know?
• 1:19:08 – The CDF and the Third Secret of Fatima
• 1:20:58 – Was Benedict Lying?
• 1:22:48 – Bottom Line
• 1:24:08 – The Jimmy Akin Podcast
• 1:24:32 – Further Resources
• 1:25:32 – Mysterious Feedback: #432 The Shepherd of Hermas
• 1:36:03 – Your mysterious feedback
• 1:36:39 – Thank you to Oasis Studio 7
• 1:36:43 – Jimmy’s YouTube channel
• 1:36:48 – Share the show / write a review
• 1:37:26 – Next Time: The 1963 Chicago Plot to Kill JFK
• 1:38:06 – Get your Mysterious merch
• 1:38:23 – Show notes
• 1:38:30 – Become a Patron
• 1:38:40 – Sponsor: Rosary Army and School of Mary
• 1:39:03 – Sponsor: The Grady Group
• 1:39:21 – Outro

This Episode is Brought to You By:

Want to Sponsor A Show?
Support StarQuest’s mission to explore the intersection of faith and pop culture by becoming a named sponsor of the show of your choice on the StarQuest network. Click to get started or find out more.