The 1963 Chicago Plot to Kill JFK

MYS444: On the morning of November 2, 1963, crowds were lining a motorcade route through Chicago that the newspapers had printed in full. President Kennedy was coming for the Army-Air Force game at Soldier Field. Then Chicago police pulled over a former Marine named Thomas Arthur Vallee, and within minutes the White House said the president wasn’t coming. Three weeks later he was killed in Dallas.

Jimmy Akin and Dom Bettinelli look at the 1963 Chicago plot to kill JFK and the two men at its center. Vallee was a John Birch Society member with a history of mental illness, a collection of weapons and, by some accounts, a job in a building overlooking the route. The Secret Service had been watching him since a pretext interview on October 30. Abraham Bolden, the first Black agent on a presidential detail, later said the Chicago office had also been warned about a four-man team with telescopic rifles. Bolden says he was framed for trying to tell the Warren Commission. He was convicted of bribery in 1964 on testimony a key witness later admitted was false, and he was pardoned in 2022.

Jimmy walks through Edwin Black’s 1975 article “The Plot to Kill JFK in Chicago,” what the House Select Committee on Assassinations found, Bolden’s interviews and his 2025 testimony to Congress, and the Secret Service’s 1995 destruction of protective survey reports for some of Kennedy’s trips that fall.

Then he tests three theories by a plain standard: not whether they can be proven, but whether they pass a smell test. Was the Chicago plot invented after the fact? Was a separate hit team stopped, perhaps with Vallee waiting to take the blame the way some believe Lee Harvey Oswald did in Dallas? Or was Vallee simply a dangerous man on his own? The answer turns out to depend on which records survived.

Plus, mysterious feedback on episode 433: ley lines and animal migration, a Dalek explanation for the Mary Celeste, and a listener’s grandfather.

Get all new episodes automatically and for free:

Follow by Email | Watch this episode and subscribe on YouTube

Help us continue to offer Jimmy Akin’s Mysterious World. Won’t you make a pledge at SQPN.com/give today?

Links for this episode:

Chapters:

  • 0:00:00 – Intro
  • 0:00:48 – November 2, 1963: Kennedy Was Due in Chicago
  • 0:01:42 – Setting the Stage: Dallas and the Warren Commission
  • 0:03:54 – Our Standard: The Smell Test
  • 0:04:59 – Chicago in 1963
  • 0:06:07 – The World in Fall 1963
  • 0:07:02 – The Coup Against Diem
  • 0:08:36 – The Army-Air Force Game at Soldier Field
  • 0:09:25 – How the Secret Service Protected the President
  • 0:10:24 – Kennedy’s Other Trips That Fall
  • 0:11:06 – Thomas Arthur Vallee
  • 0:12:38 – The John Birch Society
  • 0:14:14 – Abraham Bolden
  • 0:14:48 – The Bathroom Detail
  • 0:17:36 – Vallee’s Arrest
  • 0:18:14 – The Trip Is Called Off
  • 0:19:46 – Vallee After Dallas
  • 0:20:51 – Bolden’s Arrest and Conviction
  • 0:25:46 – Edwin Black’s 1975 Article
  • 0:31:52 – The House Select Committee on Assassinations
  • 0:34:55 – The JFK Act and the Destroyed Survey Reports
  • 0:37:02 – Bolden on Chicago Television, 2007
  • 0:40:14 – Bolden on NPR, 2008
  • 0:43:21 – JFK and the Unspeakable
  • 0:44:20 – The Released Records and Larry Hancock
  • 0:48:16 – Bolden’s Pardon
  • 0:49:28 – Bolden in 2023 and 2025
  • 0:54:44 – Thank you to Patrons
  • 0:55:17 – Sponsor: Fr. Dwight Longenecker
  • 0:56:08 – Sponsor: Gravetending Solutions
  • 0:56:49 – Theories
  • 0:58:44 – The Invented Plot
  • 0:59:59 – …Arguments Against the Invented Plot
  • 1:03:44 – The Thwarted Hit Team
  • 1:16:58 – …Arguments for the Thwarted Hit Team
  • 1:23:00 – Was Vallee the Team’s Patsy?
  • 1:27:12 – …Arguments for the Patsy Idea
  • 1:31:58 – The Independent Threat
  • 1:33:19 – …Arguments for the Independent Threat
  • 1:35:14 – Faith Perspective
  • 1:35:51 – Bottom Line
  • 1:36:57 – Further Resources
  • 1:37:24 – Mysterious Feedback: #433 Klingon or Time Lord Jesus? And More Weird Questions
  • 1:40:59 – Your mysterious feedback
  • 1:41:34 – Thank you to Oasis Studio 7
  • 1:41:39 – Jimmy’s YouTube channel
  • 1:42:16 – Next Time: The Mysteries of Imperial County
  • 1:43:16 – Share the show / write a review
  • 1:43:28 – Get your Mysterious merch
  • 1:43:37 – Show notes
  • 1:43:45 – Become a Patron
  • 1:43:53 – Sponsor: Rosary Army and School of Mary
  • 1:44:17 – Sponsor: The Grady Group
  • 1:44:36 – Outro

This Episode is Brought to You By:

The Grady Group, a Catholic company bringing financial clarity to their clients across the United States. Using safe money options to produce reasonable rates of return for their clients. Learn more by visiting GradyGroup.us.

Rosary Army. Featuring award-winning Catholic podcasts, Rosary resources, videos, and the School of Mary online community, prayer, and learning platform. Learn how to make them, pray them, and give them away while growing in your faith at RosaryArmy.com and SchoolOfMary.com

Father Dwight Longenecker. Fr. Dwight Longenecker reminds the Jimmy Akin’s Mysterious World audience that one of the most mysterious of mysteries is coming up, and that is the mystery of Christ’s nativity, otherwise known as Christmas. The Magi, along with the shepherds, are the mysterious strangers who come to visit the stable boy of Bethlehem. In his two Christmas books, Father Longenecker explores the Mystery of the Magi and the Secret of the Bethlehem Shepherds. These books will deepen your understanding of Christmas and are perfect to wrap up and put beneath the tree. To cut through all the mystery and get down to the history, check out Fr. Longenecker’s Substack and website

< href=”http://gravetendingsolutions.com/”>Grave Tending Solutions. Grave tending is a professional service and apostolate that brings peace of mind to families by caring for established gravesites. Distance and physical limitations can create barriers to maintaining a loved one’s final resting place. From planting graveside gardens to cleaning headstones, a grave tending professional provides a way for their clients to continue to care for and honor their loved ones. If you’re interested in learning more about grave tending, either as a client or as someone who’d like to enter the profession, please visit GraveTendingSolutions.com

Want to Sponsor A Show?
Support StarQuest’s mission to explore the intersection of faith and pop culture by becoming a named sponsor of the show of your choice on the StarQuest network. Click to get started or find out more.