Podcast: Download

STV022: Are we the sum of our memories? Dr. Victor Crnkovich thinks so — and Silo Season 3, Episode 2, “It’s All Good,” builds its entire hour around testing him.

Dom Bettinelli, Jeff Haecker, and Alix Murray work through the episode’s two biggest revelations. In the present, the Algorithm finally states the numbers out loud to Camille Sims: 352 years since the silos were sealed, six silos put through full resets, Silo 18’s own reset 140 years back — all of it enforced with memory-suppressing drugs. Meanwhile Juliette quietly stops taking her pills, a nurse notices, and the episode closes on two drums labeled Vitamin D+ being dragged up the great stairway. Nobody at the table believes those drums are vitamins.

In the before-times, congressman Daniel Keene learns his sister Charlotte didn’t suffer a simple brain injury — she was a subject of experimental memory suppression, and the technology ties straight to Juliette’s present. Helen the reporter adds a second bomb: not every flight carried nukes, Charlotte’s mission was aimed at Turkmenistan with bunker busters, and the aircraft were fitted with 1980s comms so they couldn’t be hacked. Dom’s read is Battlestar Galactica — somebody already knew there was an AI worth hiding from.

The heart of the discussion is Crnkovich’s philosophy. He calls human beings storytellers and meaning-makers, which the panel grants him. Then he says we’re “information propped up with meaning to tell us who we are,” and that’s where Dom parts company: meaning is something we glean, not something we manufacture, and a relativism that certain of itself refuses to sit still. Alix notes that Crnkovich’s real target is suffering — he lost his wife and daughter, chose to excise the wound rather than carry it, and is now scaling that choice up to a species. But suffering that one person refuses doesn’t disappear; it lands on somebody else. And a silo that’s been reset has no art, no music, no tradition, no theology of grief — nothing to hold onto when the pain arrives anyway.

The conversation ranges through Severance and Fallout, the Cultural Revolution and the Reformation, the silo’s deliberately awful logistics as a tool of class control, and the young women who now call themselves Juliette, trade relics of her, and say she came back from the dead to save them from their deaths. Even Crnkovich concedes there’s something between the axons and the neurons, “something like a soul,” that won’t be controlled by him or anyone. The Algorithm is trying to control exactly that — and a machine may simply not know what it’s reaching for.

Get all new episodes automatically and for free:

Follow by Email | Listen to this episode and subscribe on YouTube.

Help us continue to offer Secrets of TV. Won’t you make a pledge at GiveStarquest.com today?

Links for this episode:

• Leave us a review on Apple Podcasts!
• Join the conversation at the StarQuest Facebook page.
• Be part of the StarQuest Discord community at SQPN.com/discord
• Email us feedback or comments to [email protected]

Want to Sponsor A Show?
Support StarQuest’s mission to explore the intersection of faith and pop culture by becoming a named sponsor of the show of your choice on the StarQuest network. Click to get started or find out more.

YTCode: TRRAWUCBFCRFUMGA