Silo, S3: Whatever You Do, Don’t Go Home

Podcast: Download

STV024: The flashback was a lie. Silo showed us Bernard smothered by Sims, and in Season 3, Episode 4, “Whatever You Do, Don’t Go Home,” Juliette finds him alive in the Digger void — burned, scarred, and holding the knowledge she has been drugged out of remembering. The series didn’t withhold that scene. It fabricated one and handed it to us as fact, which is precisely what the algorithm does to the people living inside the silo.

Dom Bettinelli, Jeff Haecker, and Alix Murray work through the fourth hour of Silo Season 3 and land on the show’s central trick: the storytelling manipulates its audience the same way the algorithm manipulates its citizens. Alix reads it as consistent design, right down to the near-monochrome palette and its rationed pops of color. Jeff points out that the first Hugh Howey novel is titled Wool, and that pulling the wool over someone’s eyes operates on the story level and the meta level at once.

Then the panel gets to the harder question underneath the twist. Juliette tells Shirley she has no memory of her, and that she would still kill for her and die for her. If the memory is gone and the loyalty survives, what exactly is a person? The panel pushes back on the show’s own line that we are the sum of our memories. Alix offers muscle memory as the counter-evidence — the knitter who casts on 350 stitches without counting and comes within five every time. Something in her is counting. Something in Juliette still knows the tunnels. Dom takes it into Christian anthropology: you remain fundamentally yourself through memory loss, head injury, or a personality change, because personhood is ontological rather than accumulated.

Elsewhere in the episode, the nurse who turns and sedates Emerson instead of Juliette is the real surprise, and the panel reads Sims as the hidden hand behind it — the man who saved Bernard, placed the nurse, and volunteered for the assassination so he could fake it. His faith in the Pact is cracking at the same rate his marriage is. In the Before Times, Daniel and Helen go to ground in an ex-boyfriend’s loft after their hacker contact disappears, and a chess username called Bigfoot Lives sends Daniel back to a friend at the Pentagon. Jeff and Alix diagnose the pair as idealist and cynic, each one’s weakness the other’s correction — though Alix is blunt that she doesn’t like Helen and finds the flashback thread the weaker half of the season.

There’s also Orla Kent. The boyfriend who isn’t grieving, the ex-girlfriend who inherits her job, her father running the mines where the body turned up: all three smell a red herring built to keep Sheriff Billings looking the wrong way. And the Pez dispenser from before the collapse, sitting in a silo centuries later, still refuses to explain itself.

Get all new episodes automatically and for free:

Follow by Email | Listen to this episode and subscribe on YouTube.

Help us continue to offer Secrets of TV. Won’t you make a pledge at GiveStarquest.com today?

Links for this episode:

Want to Sponsor A Show?
Support StarQuest’s mission to explore the intersection of faith and pop culture by becoming a named sponsor of the show of your choice on the StarQuest network. Click to get started or find out more.

YTCode: TRRAWUCBFCRFUMGA

by
Secrets of TV Television 1 - 300